Tim Keller on Hidden Christmas

A meditation to inspire your Christmas celebrations!

“…deep in the human heart there are these desires—to experience the supernatural, to escape death, to know love that we can never lose, to not age but live long enough to realize our creative dreams, to fly, to communicate with nonhuman beings, to triumph over evil. If the fantasy stories are well told, we find them incredibly moving and satisfying. Why?

It is because, even though we know that factually the stories didn’t happen, our hearts long for these things, and a well-told story momentarily satisfies these desires, scratching the terrible itch.

“Beauty and the Beast” tells us there’s a love that can break us out of the beastliness that we have created for ourselves. “Sleeping Beauty” tells us we are in a kind of sleeping enchantment and there is a noble prince who can come and destroy it. We hear these stories and they stir us, because deep inside our hearts believe, or want to believe, that these things are true. Death should not be the end. We should not lose our loved ones. Evil should not triumph. Our hearts sense that even though the stories themselves aren’t true, the underlying realities behind the stories are somehow true or ought to be…

Then we come to the Christmas story. And at first glance it looks like the other legends. Here is a story about someone from a different world who breaks into ours and has miraculous powers, and can calm the storm and heal people and raise people from the dead. Then his enemies turn on him, and he is put to death, and it seems like all hope is over, but finally he rises from the dead and saves everyone.

We read that and we think, Another great fairy tale! Indeed, it looks like the Christmas story is one more story pointing to these underlying realities. But Matthew’s Gospel refutes that by grounding Jesus in history, not “once upon a time.” He says this is no fairy tale. Jesus Christ is not one more lovely story pointing to these underlying realities—Jesus is the underlying reality to which all the stories point…

If Matthew is right, that there is an evil sorcerer in this world, and we are under enchantment, and there is a noble prince who has broken the enchantment, and there is a love from which we will never be parted. And we will indeed fly someday, and we will defeat death, and in this world, now “red in tooth and claw,” someday even the trees are going to dance and sing (Psalm 65:13, 96:11–13)…

There is a scene in the movie Hook where Maggie Smith plays an elderly Wendy from the Peter Pan story. She addresses Robin Williams, a grown-up Peter Pan who has amnesia. He is amused by the stories Wendy tells his children, but at one point she stares right at him and says: “Peter, the stories are true.”

If Christmas really happened, it means the whole human race has amnesia, but the tales we love most aren’t really just entertaining escapism. The Gospel, because it is a true story, means all the best stories will be proved, in the ultimate sense, true.”

– from Hidden Christmas, by Tim Keller


An Advent Meditation for 2022 and Beyond

The difference between you and God is that God doesn’t think He’s you

                                                                                         – Anne Lamott


Advent is all about appearances. 

No, not the “outward appearance,” “I’ve got the biggest Christmas lights on my doghouse thing” (you do watch A Charlie Brown Christmas, don’t you?) 

Appearances, as we all know (yet somehow keep forgetting) can be deceiving. 

Not to say that we shouldn’t be drawn to beauty – we’re actually wired for it. Beautiful art, poetry, fiction – even great websites! – and beauty in other humans (God’s image) are all reflections and gifts of a beautiful God, not to be despised.

But the downside of all this is that we forget about the heart (1 Sam. 16:7).

Even the prophet Samuel fell into this “appearances” trap when sent to search among Jesse’s sons for the next king of Israel – the one through whom the Messiah would come. 

Surely, he reasoned, it had to be Eliab, an impressive physical specimen — but no. Abinadab? Shamma? Any of the other seven brothers? Nope. 

No, God chose the runt of the litter, the most unexpected son – David. 

But it’s not as if God looks past our thin veneer to find the “morally pure of heart” folks (a group with zero members). We find this over and over again in Scripture: ironically, those who God chooses are by all appearances weak, misfits, and miserable failures:

Noah got drunk and passed out naked.

Abraham lied and claimed Sarah wasn’t his wife.

Jacob deceived his father to steal a blessing from his brother. 

Moses murdered an Egyptian and hid him in the sand.

Rahab was a harlot.

David was an adulterer and murderer – while he was king.

Saul (Paul) persecuted the church.

Peter denied Christ… three times.

Down to you and me.

Isn’t that freeing? You need no longer pretend. In fact, it’s critical that you don’t.

“Belief,” as Francis Spufford notes, “demands that you dispense with illusion after illusion, while contemporary common sense requires continual, fluffy pretending – pretending that might as well be systematic, it’s so thoroughly incentivized by our culture.”

A Different Kind of Appearance

But while this is all true (offering great hope for the likes of us!) it’s actually the second sense of “appearances” that Advent is really about – such as: “He or she made an appearance here yesterday.” 

Or maybe think of a celebrity cameo, like Keith Richards (of the Rolling Stones) appearing in Pirates of the Caribbean, or Sean Connery as King Richard in Robin Hood

Now take that idea and magnify it a million times: the most important person ever – God himself – showed up to make an appearance to mankind. 

Clothed in real flesh- the kind that can get goosebumps, dry someone’s tears, and bleed. 

2,000 years ago. 

Appearing in Bethlehem, and beyond – Emmanuel, “God with us.” 

But now notice how the two senses of the word actually lead to one another:

Because God isn’t swayed by outward appearances, he made an appearance.  

That’s the way God works. You don’t need to impress him. Because in the final analysis, Advent isn’t about what
you did:

  • how impressive you were in your last business meeting. 
  • the success you were or hope for in your career.
  • the righteous example you think you are to everyone around you.
  • finding “3 steps to a successful x, y, or z.” 

It’s actually God making an appearance to free you from the chains of living by appearances, and the slavery of endlessly having to “measure up.” 

He walks in the room, and you can breathe.

Each year, Advent comes to remind you: your accomplishments or “to-do’s” don’t qualify you.

We only receive him if our hands are empty:

Not the labors of my hands Can fulfill thy law’s demands.

Could my zeal no respite know, Could my tears forever flow,

All for sin could not atone; Thou must save and thou alone.

Nothing in my hand I bring, Simply to thy cross I cling;

Naked, come to thee for dress, Helpless, look to thee for grace.

Foul, I to the fountain fly—Wash me, Savior, or I die!”

                                – Rock of Ages, Augustus Toplady

All that’s left for you to do is kneel in awe and wonder, and ponder his “worth-ship.” That’s what worship really is. 

This is why Advent-grace sparks celebration: it cuts through having to prove yourself. That’s why the announcement came to lowly shepherds.

Emmanuel appeared to wash us and clothe us in Himself – our true “righteousness, holiness, and salvation” (1 Cor. 1:30).  

O come, O come, Emmanuel!